Egyptian Cotton Crochet Thread vs Fine Cotton Yarn
Share
Doilies, lace collars and filet crochet are traditionally made with crochet thread: a fine, tightly twisted cotton wound on a ball. Many makers now use fine cotton yarn instead, especially for wearable lace. Both have a place. This guide explains the difference and when to choose each.
Quick answer: crochet thread is sized by number, where a higher number means a finer thread (size 10 is common; size 3 is heavier). Fine cotton yarn is sized by weight group. A super fine (fingering) cotton yarn is close to the heavier threads, around size 3, and works well for doilies, lace edgings and wearable lace. Use a steel hook for fine thread and a regular hook for yarn.
How Thread Sizes Work
Thread sizes run the opposite way to yarn weights. A size 30 thread is very fine and a size 3 thread is much heavier. Size 10 is the most common for doilies and is usually worked with a steel hook of about 1.5 to 1.75 mm.
| Thread or yarn | Typical use | Hook |
|---|---|---|
| Size 30 thread | Very fine lace, tatting-style work | Steel, about 1 mm |
| Size 10 thread | Classic doilies, filet crochet | Steel, 1.5–1.75 mm |
| Size 3 thread | Heavier doilies, edgings, light garments | Steel or 2.25–2.5 mm |
| Super fine yarn (#1) | Doilies, lace shawls, wearable lace | 2.25–3.5 mm |
| Fine yarn (#2) | Lacy tops, baby wear | 3.5–4.5 mm |
Sizes vary by brand. Always check the label and make a swatch.
Thread or Yarn: Which to Choose?
Choose thread for traditional doilies, very fine filet work and pieces that should be stiff and flat.
Choose fine cotton yarn for wearable lace, table runners, edgings on garments and anything that should drape. Yarn is softer than tightly twisted thread, and it is easier on your hands.
Why Egyptian Cotton Is Ideal for Fine Work
Long fibres, smooth strand. Egyptian cotton's extra-long staple fibres make a smooth, strong strand with very little fuzz, so every stitch stands out.
Mercerized sheen. Mercerization adds lustre and strength and helps colour stay bright.
Durability. Fine lace is washed and handled often. Strong, long-staple cotton holds up for years.
Our Choice for Fine Crochet: Scarab
Scarab is our Super Fine 100% Egyptian cotton yarn, DNA tested and mercerized, in 50 g skeins of 165 m (180 yd). It crochets at 21 stitches and 26 rows to 4 inches with a 3.25 mm (D-3) hook. For a finer, lacier result, go down to 2.5 or 2.75 mm. It is a good substitute for heavier thread in patterns that call for size 3, and it comes in the same range of colours as our other yarns, plus Undyed.
Converting a Thread Pattern to Yarn
Many vintage doily and lace patterns are written for size 10 or size 20 thread. You can work them in fine cotton yarn, but the piece will be larger.
- Make the first few rounds in your chosen yarn and hook.
- Measure the diameter and compare it with the pattern at the same round.
- Scale your expectations: a doily that measures 30 cm in size 10 thread may measure 45 to 55 cm in super fine yarn.
- Adjust the hook if the fabric looks too open or too tight. Lace in yarn usually looks best slightly firmer than you might expect.
A larger result is often a good thing. A doily pattern in fine yarn makes a lovely table centrepiece, and a small edging pattern becomes a bold trim for a cushion.
Blocking and Starching Lace
Wet your finished piece, gently squeeze out the water and pin it flat on a blocking board or towel, opening each point and picot. Let it dry completely.
For doilies that should stand firm, use a light spray starch or a starch solution before pinning. For wearable lace, skip the starch: cotton holds a blocked shape well on its own and stays soft.
Projects for Fine Egyptian Cotton
- Doilies and table centrepieces
- Lace edgings for towels, pillowcases and handkerchiefs
- Filet crochet panels and curtains
- Lace collars and cuffs
- Christening blankets and heirloom baby wear
- Lightweight lace tops and shawls
Keep reading: super fine and fingering cotton yarn.
Crochet Thread FAQ
Is crochet thread the same as yarn?
Not quite. Thread is tightly twisted and sized by number. Yarn is softer and sized by weight group. The finest yarns and heaviest threads overlap.
What size thread is closest to fingering weight yarn?
Size 3 thread is usually closest to fingering (super fine) yarn. Swatch to confirm, as brands vary.
What hook do I use for size 10 thread?
Usually a steel hook of about 1.5 to 1.75 mm.
